Saturday, December 28, 2019
Commonly Confused Words Bring and Take
The verbs bring and take both involve movement, but in different directions in relation to the speaker. Definitions In most cases,à bring suggests movement toward the speaker (Bring it to me) while take suggests a movement away from the speaker (Take it to your brother). Heres how Charles Harrington Elster illustrates the rule in The Accidents of Style: [W]hen you go to a restaurant they bring the food to your table and take your money when youre done. Where the point of view is uncertain or irrelevant, either verb may be used. In some cases, as mentioned in the usage notes below, idiom determines the choice between bring and take. Examples Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia (the title of a film directed by Sam Peckinpah, 1974)Take Me Out to the Ball Game (song by Jack Norworth and Albert Von Tilzer, 1908)Take This Job and Shove It (song by David Allan Coe, 1978)If this is coffee, please bring me some tea; but if this is tea, please bring me some coffee. (attributed to Abraham Lincoln)Logic will get you from A to B. Imagination will take you everywhere.(attributed to Albert Einstein) Usage Notes Mignon Fogarty: I suspect that one reason people get confused about bring and take is that there are many exceptions to the basic rules. For example, idioms such as bring home the bacon and take a bath and phrasal verbs such as bring up, bring about, take down, and take after dont comply with the rule that bring means to cause something to go to the speaker and take means to cause something to go away from the speaker. Charles Harrington Elster: [B]ring is established in expressions like bring to light, bring to justice, and bring to the table, perhaps because theres a figurative implication that the writer or speaker is in the light, at the seat of justice, or at the table. Bryan A. Garner: The rule becomes complicated when the movement has nothing to do with the speaker--e.g.: When my dad was courting my mom, a single mother of two, he used to take her a bag of groceries instead of flowers. In such a situation, the choice of bring or take depends on motion toward or away from whatever is being discussed. So in the previous example, bring would work as well if the point of view was that of the mother rather than the father. Patricia T. OConner: [T]here are gray areas where the bringing and the taking arent so clear. Say youre a dinner guest and you decide to tote a bottle of wine along with you. Do you bring it or do you take it? The answer depends on your perspectiveââ¬âon which end of the journey youre talking about, the origin or the destination. What shall I bring, white or red? you ask the host. Bring red, he replies. (Both you and he are speaking of the wine from the point of view of its destinationââ¬âthe host.) Ten minutes later, youre asking the wine merchant, What should I take, a Burgundy or a Bordeaux? Take this one, she says. (Both you and she are speaking of the wine from the point of view of its origin.) Clear? If not, pour yourself a glass, take it easy, and say what sounds most natural. Youll probably be right. Practice (a) We will _____ this pie to Grandfather Goosey Gander.(b) Dame Tuckett was kind enough to _____ us a loaf of bread.(c) Buy the ticket, _____ the ride. (Hunter S. Thompson)(d) You didnt need to _____ me flowers. Answers to Practice Exercises:à Bring and Take (a) We willà takeà this pie to Grandfather Goosey Gander.(b) Dame Tuckett was kind enough toà bringà us a loaf of bread.(c) Buy the ticket,à takeà the ride. (Hunter S. Thompson)(d) You didnt need toà bringà me flowers.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.